United States
Canada
Why Material Choice Is the Whole Ballgame
Somewhere around month four or five, your baby discovers their hands aren’t enough. They want something to chew — hard. That’s when the teether aisle gets overwhelming fast, and the stakes feel higher than they probably should, but also kind of aren’t, because what goes in a baby’s mouth for hours a day actually matters.
The short version: traditional teethers may contain harmful chemicals such as BPA, phthalates, PVC, and lead, which can leach into a baby’s mouth and pose health risks. And these products wear down over time when exposed to heat and saliva from all that chewing action, meaning that saving money in the short term can have costly effects over time if you’re exposing your child to harmful compounds.
The three materials worth knowing about in 2026 are food-grade silicone, natural rubber, and hardwood (typically maple or beech). Each has real trade-offs.
Silicone used in teething products is soft on tender gums but strong enough not to be torn apart, often made with a naturally anti-bacterial material that doesn’t hold onto foreign odors or fragrances — and it’s BPA-free, PVC-free, phthalate-free, and latex-free. Silicone is made using silica, a natural substance derived from sand, which means it does not contain any harmful chemicals that regular plastics do, such as BPA and phthalates.
Natural rubber has its own appeal. Natural rubber is derived from the sap of the Hevea tree, a renewable and biodegradable material that offers a soft yet resilient texture perfect for little gums. Unlike synthetic materials, which can feel cold or overly firm, natural rubber has an organic warmth that babies instinctively respond to — it gives just enough resistance to soothe sore gums while remaining flexible and safe for mouthing. The one caveat: latex allergies in infants younger than 1 year have been documented from teethers and pacifiers, with symptoms including wheezing, facial swelling, rash, or anaphylaxis. If there’s any family history of latex sensitivity, silicone is the safer call.
Hardwood — specifically beech and maple — rounds out the options. Beechwood is naturally antibacterial and antimicrobial and won’t splinter when the baby chews on it. When you’re looking for a teething option that is a little harder than silicone, beech wood fits the bill, as it will also help babies strengthen their newly forming teeth and their roots. The maintenance requirement is real, though: wood can’t be submerged in water or run through a dishwasher, and it benefits from occasional conditioning with a food-safe oil.
One certification to look for regardless of material: toys that meet safety standards like ASTM or CPSC certifications ensure the toy is safe for infant use.
The Top Non-Toxic Teething Toys of 2026
1. Loulou Lollipop Silicone Teethers
Loulou Lollipop’s silicone teether line — which includes original designs like the iconic donut, ice cream cone, llama, and macaron shapes — is a strong starting point for parents who want material transparency without sacrificing aesthetics. Every teether toy and ring is safety-tested by a leading third-party laboratory to ensure that they are entirely free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, lead, cadmium, and other toxic substances, and that they are compliant with Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) regulations. Made from natural silicone found in sand using a manufacturing process that meets the highest environmental standards, and free from harmful chemicals, they feature 100% water-based and food-safe inks that are injected into the silicone instead of applied on top — a detail that matters when a baby is gnawing on a toy for hours.
Silicone is non-porous, meaning it is hypoallergenic and won’t become a safe space for germs to live, and it’s easy to clean — it can simply be tossed in the dishwasher at the end of the day. For parents who want the combination of silicone and wood, Loulou Lollipop’s silicone and beechwood teething rings pair the softness of food-grade silicone with the firmer resistance of beech. Loulou Lollipop is the original designer of silicone donut teethers, ice cream cone teethers, and macaron teethers. As a certified B Corp brand with 10+ years of product development, their safety standards go beyond basic compliance.
Best for: Parents who want CPSC-certified, dishwasher-safe teethers with design-forward shapes and fully transparent material sourcing.
2. Mushie Silicone Teethers
Mushie has carved out a distinct aesthetic in the baby space — muted Scandinavian palettes, minimal branding — and their teethers match that approach. The bunny teether features an easy-grip design, helps develop fine motor skills, is dishwasher safe, and free from BPA, BPS, PVC, and phthalates. Made from 100% non-toxic, food-grade silicone and designed to be easy to grasp by tiny fingers, their teethers are safe for babies to use.
The No-Drop Sensory Teether is worth a mention specifically: made from 100% non-toxic, food-grade silicone, it’s safe for chewing as babies seek relief for sore gums, and with an easy-to-grip interior handle, littles can improve fine motor skills while exploring the soothing textured surfaces. Mushie’s color palette tends to appeal to parents who want nursery-coordinated toys, and their solid construction holds up well over time.
Best for: Aesthetic-first families who want minimalist design paired with solid food-grade silicone safety credentials.
3. Sophie la Girafe (Natural Rubber)
Sophie has been around since 1961 and remains one of the most recognized teethers on the market. She is made from 100% natural rubber derived from the Hevea tree and painted with food-grade paint, making her free from BPA, phthalates, and harmful chemicals — and she meets strict international safety standards including EU EN 71 and US ASTM F963.
The multi-part design is the real draw: Sophie has dark contrasting spots and a flexible, soft, lightweight body, with many parts to chew — ears, horns, legs. That variety of surfaces means babies can find the spot that feels best on their specific gum discomfort. Each Sophie requires 14 manual steps to produce.
One honest maintenance note: Sophie cannot be submerged in water. Sophie la Girafe can develop mold inside if water enters through the squeaker hole — this is not a defect, it is a result of submerging or rinsing her in water, which traps moisture inside the hollow body where it cannot dry out. Surface-wipe cleaning only.
Best for: Parents who want a natural rubber option with decades of safety data and a sensory-rich design — and who are comfortable with the cleaning limitations.
4. Itzy Ritzy Silicone Teethers
Itzy Ritzy has a wide teether lineup, and their safety story is consistent across it. All Itzy Ritzy products undergo comprehensive testing in accordance with the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA), which was established by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) in 2008 to regulate the use of materials like lead and phthalates in children’s products. Their Ritzy Rattle baby teething toy is crafted from 100% food-grade silicone and free from harmful chemicals like PVC, phthalates, lead, cadmium, and BPA.
The Ritzy Teether for Molars is a practical pick for older teethers: the textured hollow tubes on the Ritzy Teether collapse and flex, reaching both front teeth and back molars, with multiple textures on the flexible, soft tubes making them perfect for front, side, and back teething. For very young babies who haven’t yet developed the grip to hold a standard teether, the Itzy Mitt is a wearable teething mitten designed for babies who haven’t yet developed fine motor skills to hold traditional teethers, featuring a textured silicone surface that babies can chew on to soothe sore gums and made of food-grade materials.
Best for: Parents who want a full-stage teether system — from early infancy through molar teething — all within one brand’s safety framework.
5. Bannor Toys Wooden and Silicone Teethers (Made in USA)
Bannor Toys operates out of Iowa and has been handcrafting wooden baby toys since 2011. Their teethers lean into the natural-material ethos more than most. Their ring teethers are made using food-grade silicone beads and rock-hard maple, which is naturally resistant to bacteria and non-splintering wood, so it’s safe for baby to gum on for hours. Their wood finish is a 100% organic beeswax and flaxseed oil mixture that is all natural and nontoxic — the perfect finish for baby’s mouth.
The silicone components carry serious certification credentials: silicone beads are permanently attached, 100% non-toxic, lead-free, BPA-free, cadmium-free, mercury-free, phthalate-free, FDA approved, CPSIA compliant, and have ASTM International Certification and CE Certification. A practical tip from the brand: wood and silicone hold cold for a while, so stick them in the fridge for an hour first and the cool sensation will soothe baby’s gums.
Best for: Parents who want US-made, natural-material teethers with heirloom-quality construction and minimal synthetic components.
What to Check Before You Buy
A few practical filters that cut through the noise:
Certification language matters. Look specifically for CPSC/CPSIA compliance and third-party lab testing — not just brand claims. Look for teethers that have undergone safety testing and certification from reputable organizations such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) or the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA), as certification ensures that the teether meets stringent safety standards and is free from hazards such as choking hazards or toxic materials.
Solid construction over hollow. Avoid toys with small crevices or hollow areas where water can get trapped and mold can grow — solid designs are much easier to keep dry and mold-free. This applies especially to natural rubber toys with squeakers.
Size relative to your baby’s hands. Keep in mind the size of the toy — you want to make sure it’s small enough for your baby to comfortably hold and chew on, but not so small that it poses a choking hazard. In general, teething toys should be about the size of your baby’s fist.
Texture variety. Look for a toy that has some sort of texture to it — this will help your baby massage their gums and provide relief from the discomfort of teething. Look for toys with raised bumps or ridges, or ones made of a softer material like silicone.
Cleaning logistics. Teething toys are constantly covered in drool, so being able to clean them easily is a must. Food-grade silicone is generally the most forgiving: most options are top-rack dishwasher safe or can be sterilized. Wood requires more care — wiping rather than soaking — but its natural antimicrobial properties help compensate. Always check for damage before each use: even the best non-toxic teething toys can show signs of wear after repeated use, so check regularly for cracks, tears, or loose parts that could become choking hazards, and if you notice any damage, replace the toy to ensure your baby’s safety.
For parents who want to go deeper on material safety and how to read ingredient labels on baby products, Loulou Lollipop’s guide to choosing non-toxic baby teethers is a useful reference — it breaks down specific chemicals to avoid and explains why food-safe silicone is the standard to look for.