United States
Canada
Why Softness Is the Wrong Thing to Overlook
Most parents shopping for teething toys fixate on shape, color, or how photogenic the toy looks in a flat-lay. Softness — the single quality that matters most for a newborn’s gum tissue — tends to come last, if it comes up at all.
Here’s the clinical reality: teething gums have a redder, more swollen appearance as well as increased sensitivity. And teething pain typically begins at 4 months of age and can last up to a week, a few days before and after the tooth erupts. But some babies start earlier. Most babies will get their first tooth between 6 and 12 months of age, although some may begin teething as early as 3 months. For those early teethers, the gum tissue hasn’t had months of oral stimulation to toughen up — it’s genuinely tender, and the wrong toy can make things worse instead of better.
Pediatric dentists have a consistent shortlist of what to look for. Material is the most important safety factor: pediatric dentists consistently recommend teethers made from food-grade silicone or natural rubber, free of BPA, phthalates, PVC, parabens, and synthetic dyes. Beyond material, texture matters — babies respond well to toys that offer gentle resistance, a bit of softness, and small ridges that massage sore gums, and easy-to-hold shapes are essential for younger infants who are still developing grip strength.
One safety point worth stating plainly: pediatric dentists caution against anything too hard or frozen solid, so make sure you’re only chilling a teether in the fridge for a mild effect. A rock-hard frozen toy pressed against inflamed newborn gums is a problem, not a solution.
The Criteria: How This List Is Ranked
Each pick below is evaluated on four factors pediatric dentists actually use:
1. Silicone grade and purity — food-grade silicone is the baseline. Anything less is a pass.
2. Structural softness — how much give the toy has under light biting pressure. For newborns and early teethers, this matters more than texture variety.
3. One-piece construction — any teether that can separate into parts, including those with detachable handles, beads, or liquid-filled compartments, poses a choking or aspiration risk and should be avoided.
4. Grip accessibility — for babies at the earliest teething stage, the ideal teething toy is lightweight, easy to grasp, and soft enough for early chewing. A toy a newborn can’t hold independently still has value — parents can guide it — but ergonomic grip design extends the toy’s useful window considerably.
Nothing on this list contains liquid filling, detachable beads, or hard plastic components. All picks are food-grade silicone or close equivalents.
Silicone Teethers Ranked by Softness (Softest First)
1. Loulou Lollipop Silicone Single Teether — Softest Overall for Early-Stage Gums
For newborns and babies showing early gum sensitivity, the Loulou Lollipop Silicone Single Teether is the softest structured pick on this list. Made from 100% premium quality food-grade silicone, it features nubby textures on both sides to soothe sore gums, and the heart-shaped cut-out allows for attaching an optional clip. It is tested regularly at a government-accredited lab to meet and exceed safety standards.
The silicone used across Loulou Lollipop’s teether line is free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, lead, and cadmium and made from natural silicone found in sand using a manufacturing process that meets the highest environmental standards, free from harmful chemicals and featuring 100% water-based and food-safe inks that are injected into the silicone instead of applied on top. That last detail matters for newborns: surface-applied inks can flake; injected inks cannot.
The flat, paddle-like shape is sized for small hands that haven’t yet developed a full grip. Parents can hold it against the gum line during the earliest weeks, and babies can manage it independently by around 3–4 months. The clip attachment means it can be tethered to a onesie, reducing the number of times it hits the floor per day (a real concern once babies start batting objects around).
Softness rating: 5/5 — yields under the lightest pressure; appropriate from birth onward.
2. Loulou Lollipop Daisy Silicone Teether Set — Soft with Structural Grip
The Daisy Silicone Teether Set steps up the ergonomics slightly. This set features a unique one-piece molded strap holder, the teether measures 2.75 inches across providing ample space for little hands to grasp and explore, and it is made from 100% premium soft food-grade silicone, free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, lead, and cadmium. The wider diameter gives a newborn’s parent something to hold during guided teething sessions, and the petal-shaped edges offer varied surface contact without any hard ridges.
Softness rating: 4.5/5 — slightly firmer than the single teether due to its wider cross-section, but still appropriate for 0–3 months.
3. Comotomo Silicone Teether — Widely Recommended, Moderate Softness
The Comotomo is probably the most-cited silicone teether in pediatric dental roundups. The four soft, finger-like protrusions give babies a variety of biting surfaces that mimic the sensation of gnawing on their own hands, and the material is food-grade silicone free of BPA, phthalates, plastic, nitrosamines, and lead. The one-piece design makes for safe gnawing and it’s heat-resistant, so it can go in the dishwasher.
The finger protrusions are soft but have more structural resistance than a flat paddle teether — which makes the Comotomo better suited for babies who have developed some bite strength, typically 3 months and up. For a true newborn with no biting pressure, the protrusion shape can be harder to use without parental assistance.
Softness rating: 3.5/5 — soft enough for sensitive gums, but the protrusion structure adds mild resistance that works better once some oral muscle control develops.
4. Teething Mitten (Silicone-Tipped) — Best for Pre-Grip Stage
For babies under 8 weeks who can’t hold anything reliably, a silicone-tipped teething mitten sidesteps the grip problem entirely. For babies who haven’t yet mastered the grip, teething mittens worn on the hand stay in place, catch drool, and have textured surfaces built right in for chewing relief. The silicone nub on most mitten designs is thin and pliable — softer than a structured ring — and the fabric body is machine washable.
The tradeoff: mittens have a shorter useful window. Once a baby develops intentional grip (usually around 3–4 months), they’ll pull the mitten off and chew on the fabric instead.
Softness rating: 4/5 — the silicone tip is very soft, but the overall product is more of a bridge solution than a long-term teether.
5. Natural Rubber Teethers (e.g., Sophie La Girafe) — Soft but Different Material Profile
Natural rubber teethers like Sophie La Girafe sit close to food-grade silicone in terms of softness. The Sophie La Girafe teether is BPA-free and made from natural rubber and food-quality paint; it’s safe, has plenty of squish, and is all one piece, so there aren’t any components that can break off. Natural rubber is softer than most plastics but tends to degrade faster than silicone under repeated sterilization. Parents who boil or steam-sterilize frequently may find silicone holds up better over time.
Softness rating: 4/5 — comparable softness to silicone, but material longevity under repeated cleaning cycles is lower.
What to Avoid (And Why Pediatric Dentists Are Clear on This)
A few categories come up consistently in dental guidance as things to skip, especially for newborns.
Frozen teethers. The AAP recommends chilled (refrigerated), not frozen. A rock-hard frozen teether can bruise or damage delicate gum tissue. Refrigerating a silicone teether for 20–30 minutes gives a gentle cooling effect without the hardness risk.
Liquid-filled rings. These were once popular, but if the ring is punctured or breaks, it can leak chemicals or bacteria-laden fluids. One-piece solid silicone avoids this entirely.
Teething jewelry. Amber necklaces and silicone bead bracelets pose a serious choking and strangulation risk, and the American Academy of Pediatrics and most dental professionals urge parents not to use any wearable teething jewelry.
Benzocaine gels. The FDA warns against benzocaine products for children under 2 — they can cause methemoglobinemia, a rare but life-threatening blood disorder. Physical teething toys are the safer, evidence-backed alternative.
And a note on inspection: inspect every teether weekly and throw it out at the first sign of cracks, soft spots, peeling, mold, or any structural failure. Silicone is durable, but no teether lasts forever under daily use.
A Practical Note on Chilling and Cleaning
Chilling a silicone teether is one of the most effective ways to extend its usefulness during a rough teething day. Most silicone and rubber teething rings can be safely refrigerated; a chilled (not frozen) toy can reduce inflammation and provide a welcome distraction, but they should be washed frequently with warm, soapy water to prevent bacteria or mold.
Most silicone and rubber teethers can be refrigerated for 30 to 60 minutes before use — enough time to get a meaningful cooling effect without the toy becoming uncomfortably cold. For parents rotating through multiple teethers (a good strategy, since preferences shift as gum soreness moves around the mouth), keeping one in the fridge at all times is a low-effort habit that pays off.
Cleaning is straightforward with food-grade silicone: warm soapy water handles most situations, and many silicone teethers are dishwasher safe on the top rack. Replace a teether at the first sign of cracks, peeling, soft spots, mold, or torn seams — even small tears can hide bacteria.
For parents building out a newborn teething kit, the Loulou Lollipop teether collection offers food-grade silicone options across several shapes and sizes — useful for rotating textures as a baby’s oral needs change across the first year. The brand’s teethers are designed to be giftable as well as functional, which matters when you’re stocking up before a baby arrives and aren’t sure yet which shape will land.