United States
Canada
The Short Answer Is Yes — With One Condition
Boiling a silicone teether is one of the safest and most effective ways to sterilize it, but only if the teether is made from 100% food-grade silicone. That qualifier matters more than it might seem.
Food-grade silicone is chemically inert — it doesn’t react with heat, acids, or the contents of your baby’s mouth. Its molecular structure stays stable at temperatures well above boiling point (100°C / 212°F), which means a 3–5 minute boil is nowhere close to causing any breakdown of the material. High-quality food-grade silicone typically handles continuous heat up to 220–230°C without warping or releasing compounds, so a pot of simmering water poses no structural or chemical risk to the teether.
The concern parents sometimes have — that boiling might cause the silicone to leach harmful chemicals — applies to plastics and lower-grade synthetic materials, not to certified food-grade silicone. Unlike many plastics that begin to degrade under heat and release endocrine-disrupting chemicals, food-grade silicone maintains its structural integrity at extreme temperatures. It contains no BPA, phthalates, PVC, lead, or cadmium to begin with, and the heat of boiling water doesn’t change that.
Where things get more complicated: not every teether on the market is made from a single piece of pure silicone. Gel-filled teethers, for example, can burst when boiled — a real ingestion hazard. Teethers with wooden components should never be submerged in boiling water, as wood expands and cracks under heat. And low-quality silicone products that contain plastic fillers may behave unpredictably. The pinch test is a quick check: if you twist a flat section of the silicone and white streaks appear, the product likely contains filler material and may not be safe to boil.
Why Regular Sterilization Matters More Than You Think
A teether spends a lot of time in contact with saliva, dropped on floors, tucked into diaper bags, and occasionally mouthed by curious pets or older siblings. That’s a meaningful accumulation of bacteria, viruses, and surface contaminants — and a quick rinse under the tap doesn’t address all of it.
For babies under 12 months, pediatric guidance generally recommends sterilizing all items that come into regular contact with the mouth, including pacifiers, bottles, and teethers. A practical routine that works for most families: wash with mild soap and warm water daily, and sterilize by boiling or steaming once or twice a week. During illness — a cold, a stomach bug, anything contagious — sterilize after every single use.
And any time a teether hits a public surface (a restaurant floor, a waiting room chair, a shopping cart), treat it as a full sterilization event rather than a quick wipe. The bacteria load on high-traffic public surfaces is significantly higher than what a soap rinse can reliably eliminate.
Silicone has one meaningful advantage here over other teether materials: its smooth, non-porous surface doesn’t provide the microscopic crevices where bacteria tend to embed and multiply. That said, silicone surfaces can accumulate thin oil films from saliva and the environment, which is why consistent washing — not just sterilizing — matters.
Step-by-Step: How to Boil a Silicone Teether
The process is straightforward, but a few details make a difference.
What you need: A clean pot, enough water to fully submerge the teether, and tongs or a slotted spoon.
Step 1 — Wash first. Before sterilizing, rinse the teether under warm running water and wash it with mild, fragrance-free baby soap. Remove any visible residue. Sterilization works on clean surfaces; boiling a teether that still has food debris on it is less effective.
Step 2 — Bring water to a full boil. Use enough water that the teether can move freely and stay fully submerged. A rolling boil — not just simmering — is what you want.
Step 3 — Submerge and time it. Lower the teether into the boiling water using tongs. Boil for 3 to 5 minutes. There’s no meaningful benefit to going longer under normal circumstances, and extended boiling cycles over many months can gradually affect the appearance of the silicone (though not its safety).
Step 4 — Remove carefully. Use tongs or a slotted spoon to lift the teether out. Place it on a clean surface or drying rack.
Step 5 — Cool completely before use. This is non-negotiable. Silicone retains heat longer than you might expect. Allow the teether to air dry and reach room temperature before giving it to your baby. Never test the temperature by putting it in your own mouth — use the back of your wrist.
Step 6 — Store it clean. Once dry, store the teether in a clean, dry container or a sealed bag. Avoid tossing it loose into a diaper bag where it can pick up surface bacteria from other items. Never store it while still damp — moisture encourages bacterial growth.
Other Sterilization Methods That Work (and One That Doesn’t)
Boiling is the most accessible method, but it’s not the only one that works for food-grade silicone teethers.
Steam sterilizers — both electric countertop models and microwave steam bags — are a reliable alternative. They reach temperatures comparable to boiling and are convenient if you’re already sterilizing bottles or pacifiers. Most food-grade silicone handles steam sterilization without any issue.
Dishwasher (top rack) is fine for daily cleaning and light sanitizing. Place the teether on the top rack, away from the heating element at the bottom. Use a mild detergent. This method is convenient but probably falls short of a full sterilization, especially if your dishwasher runs at lower temperatures. It’s a good daily maintenance option, not a replacement for boiling or steaming after illness or a public drop.
Microwaving without water is not recommended. While silicone itself can handle microwave heat, microwaving without water creates uneven hot spots that may not fully sterilize the teether and don’t offer the consistent germ-killing effect of boiling or steam.
Chemical sterilizing solutions (like those used for baby bottles) can be used if you follow the product instructions carefully. Rinse the teether thoroughly afterward to remove any residue before giving it to your baby.
For Loulou Lollipop’s silicone teethers, the care guidance includes top-rack dishwasher safe use and sterilizer compatibility — consistent with what 100% food-grade silicone supports. The brand’s teethers are made from food-grade silicone and are free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, lead, and cadmium, and are tested by independent labs to meet CPSIA safety standards.
When to Replace a Teether, Not Just Sterilize It
Boiling and steaming are effective, but they can’t reverse physical wear. Inspect teethers regularly — look for deep scratches, surface cracks, tearing, or any discoloration that wasn’t there before. These aren’t just cosmetic issues: damaged surfaces can harbor bacteria in ways that sterilization may not fully address, and any tearing creates a potential choking hazard.
High-quality food-grade silicone is durable and rarely develops these issues quickly, especially compared to plastic teethers that tend to degrade faster with repeated sterilization cycles. But no teether lasts forever. If you’re unsure whether a teether is still in good condition, err on the side of replacement.
For parents building out their teething toolkit, Loulou Lollipop’s teether collection — which includes the brand’s original silicone donut, ice cream, and macaron designs — offers a range of shapes and textures designed with both gum relief and hygiene in mind. Each is made from 100% food-grade silicone, so the boiling method described above applies without reservation.